Thursday, March 10, 2016

BDS Against a Repressive Turkey: Coming Soon?*

Haaretz: "The government's seizure of Zaman, the largest Turkish daily newspaper, is the latest episode in a state-sponsored campaign to silence dissent. And PR stardust won't be able to cover it up."

Louis Fishman Mar 06, 2016 

American television audiences recently have been privy to a growing number of Turkish Airlines commercials which were screened during the evenings of the Superbowl and the star-studded Hollywood Oscar awards. These were not your normal airline commercial. Rather, they were an advert for the upcoming superhero feature movie Batman v Superman, of which Turkish Airlines is a sponsor. The ads 'offer' passengers imaginary trips to the cities of Gotham and Metropolis.

The upcoming March release of the movie is aimed at reversing Turkey’s tourism tough times. Terrorist attacks have wiped the shine off the country's image: the suicide bombing in the heart of Istanbul in January targeted tourists (10 German visitors were killed), while tourism to the coastal city of Antalya—a magnet for Russian tourists—has dwindled following Turkey’s downing of a Russian jet  last October. The Chamber of Commerce and Industry of Antalya, desperate for the state to intervene, suggested the government step up and invite Madonna, Jennifer Lopez, even Justin Bieber, to lure tourists back.

However, Turkey’s problems are much greater than just convincing tourists to keep coming. Since regaining a parliamentary majority in November, President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, and his obedient Prime Minister, Ahmet Davutoglu, seem to be doing their utmost to lead Turkey into darker times.  

Journalists carry an injured woman after Turkish riot-police used tear gas to disperse supporters in front of the headquarters of Turkish daily newspaper Zaman, Istanbul, March 5, 2016AFP

Proof of this came again this past weekend. On Friday, the state seized the opposition media outlet Zaman, which is identified with the Gulen movement, his sworn rivals, evicting its employees from their offices, and taking over its building with brutal police force.

Within 24 hours Turkey’s largest daily had its chief editor replaced by a pro-government state appointed trustee . The AKP government is now one step closer to completely silencing all criticism. This goes beyond the press: almost 2000 cases have been opened against individuals for the crime of insulting the president.   

Turkey’s leaders' obsessional silencing of their critics could, though, now have reached a peak level that can only damage them. The ruling AKP worked hard to build its strong international image during most of the first decade following the year 2000. But the government's targeting of academics (both Turkish and international)  who dare to speak out against the Turkish state's war against its civilian population as part of its conflict with the PKK has outraged the world, though the outcry has been less intense regarding the actual, harsh human rights violations committed by the Turkish state itself in that war.   

Responding to the government crackdown on academics, the Middle East Students Association (MESA) issued two statements calling on the Turkish government to “take note of mounting international condemnation of the erosion of democratic rights and freedoms in Turkey, particularly in connection with the tendency of public prosecutors to intimidate political opponents and academic critics through abuses of the powers of criminal investigation and prosecution.” 

And just two weeks ago the International Political Science Association (IPSA) suddenly cancelled their 2016 summer World Congress scheduled to take place in Istanbul, relocating to an as yet-unannounced European city. True, IPSA stated that the cancellation was due to the “deterioration of the security situation in Turkey and the region.”

However, it went on to highlight this decision was also made since it could not “provide an environment favorable to the exchange of intellectual ideas.” That sent a strong message that the cancellation related to the government's repression of freedom of thought at Turkish universities.

If that wasn't enough, last week thirty professors at Columbia University called on its president Lee Bollinger to denounce the recent suppression of academics in Turkey. They also called on Bollinger to suspend activities of its Istanbul-based global center if Turkey continues to take steps against academics. It seems unlikely at this point that their call will trigger action. But Bollinger will face more pressure if the situation deteriorates for the university's own academics.

Only a few weeks ago he declared to students that, in the case of Istanbul or any of the international Columbia branches, "If they start restricting [our] academic freedom … we’re done. We’re out of there. We close shop. We can be out in a number of days. We can be out in 24 hours.”

Such examples should send a strong signal to Turkey that if it does not reconsider the ethical and legal justness of its actions it will face more sanctions and further isolation. Just as Israel is challenged daily by the Palestinian Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement, Turkey could face a growing and concerted opposition among university students, academia, and leftist movements abroad.

However, just as in Israel, voluntary international sanctions could have the reverse effect that the activists intend: strengthening the government’s hold over its electorate through reactionary politics, isolating internal voices of change amidst a failed opposition.     

What is clear however is that even glamorous PR can't hide broken and ugly realities, neither stuffing Oscar swagbags with a luxury free trip to Israel nor featuring your national airline in a major motion picture.  Turkey is hitting such a low state of affairs that even Superman or Batman can't save the country, much less Justin Bieber

*This article appeared in Haaretz on March 6, 2106. Click here for article.

Friday, March 4, 2016

Notes from Kastellorizo-Some Thoughts on Working with Refugees in Turkey and Greece

My last blog post criticized the New York Times for its insensitivity it showed to Syrian refugees in a recent article on swimming tours taking place between Turkey and Greece. Obviously, as refugees are dying in these waters, the lack of reference to this was an outrage. 

A dear friend of mine Shellie Corman, who is a long term resident in Turkey and who has been involved with helping Syrian refugees for years, is currently on the Greek island Kastellorizo organizing aid for refugees, just a short way from the Turkish city of Kas. I asked if she would so kindly write something for my blog. I thank her for agreeing to share with her thoughts about the state of the refugees and the work she and other volunteers are doing.  

 Notes from Kastellorizo

After watching the refugee situation and getting involved with some groups helping refugees in Istanbul for the past few years, I decided to come over to the Greek side to work directly with arrivals coming from Turkey by boat on their journey to what they believe will be a better life, or at least a safer place for now.   Here is what I have seen and learned in the past few days on the ground.  

I arrived here from Kas, Turkey with a group of foreigners that all volunteered to help distribute donated clothing to people who either left everything behind, lost their things at sea, or arrived soaking wet.  We outfitted numerous families, many of them with small children in warm jackets, pants, socks, shoes, hats, and had some lovely personal interactions which I think is also important to people that must feel totally abandoned by the world.     

I quickly realized that on this small island, population 200, there was a resistance to the refugees.  They are overwhelmed by the stream of arrivals, mostly Muslims, and looking so different to what they are used to seeing.  After 3 days here we were woken up at 3:45 a.m. with the news that  the clothing center was on fire.  It was quite obviously  arson.  Thousand of euros worth of clothes, shoes, hats, gloves, pampers, hygiene products etc. went up in flames.

Here is what I have seen and learned by being here.   The arriving refugees are so varied in terms of countries of origin, economic levels, education levels, age. ( from 1 month to 80 years old). Tribal people, doctors, shepherds,engineers,  Sunnis Muslims, Shiites , Yazidis,  Christians and many other layers of society  all  thrown into the same boat, no pun intended.  

There had been a sleeping hall which was closed down by the mayor a week before I arrived, the clothing distribution center was burned and so virtually there is very little being done on an organized level for the arriving refugees.   A very sad time in history for humanity. We have not learned from our past mistakes.