Monday, February 8, 2010

Turkey’s Forgotten Children: The Story of a 15-year old Girl named Berivan

Often it is easier to ignore a situation than to write about it. Today’s entry is especially disturbing since it is about children who have become entangled in a political struggle, and as a result, have ended up with hefty prison terms. Further, outside of human rights organizations, it seems as most people, including Turkish citizens themselves, are unaware of the huge injustice which is taking place. Until now, my blog has focused mostly on analysis. However, this piece goes beyond analysis and I hope it will join forces with others who are working for a more just Turkey. There is no doubt that great steps have been taken; but how a country over a three-year span can try almost 3000 minors for political crimes simply seems incomprehensible.*

Last year, Prime Minister Erdogan setoff on an ambitious ‘Kurdish initiative,’ which I have highlighted in some of my past posts. This was basically an extension of the AKP’s policy which began in 2002 and was set towards relaxing strict policies placed on the Kurdish population. Almost immediately the banned Kurdish language was allowed to enter the public sphere. Overnight, bars and clubs which use to be closed down for having Kurdish music were now the spot to hang out with an extremely happy Kurdish population proudly singing in their mother tongue. A few years back, the official Turkish television(TRT) started a Kurdish language station, and more recently universities have started contemplating teaching Kurdish (as a foreign language). Tangible progress has been made. After the last elections, the DTP (Kurdish) party formed a coalition in the parliament and during the last year the AKP, together with the DTP, worked together on a Kurdish initiative; basically, a program set to find a political solution to ending the conflict, in place of a military one. Things were moving forward. However, following the constitutional court’s official closure of the DTP, and with the party leaders publicly expressing their allegiance to outlawed and imprisoned Abdullah Ocalan, the initiative has all but been suspended.

It is in this context, I am writing the following piece. Right before I left Turkey for New York, I read an article in the daily Sabah, about a 15 year old girl who was arrested for throwing rocks at police in protest and chanting pro-PKK slogans. The next day it made headlines in Taraf , and its editor, Ahmet Altan, dedicated a column to the topic, in addition to two news article, which appeared the same day (January 28, 2010). The girl’s name is Berivan. She was arrested in the Southeastern city of Batman and is currently held in the Diyarbakir prison. She received a total of 13.5 years in jail, but due to her age it was cut down to 7.9 years. Taraf provides a quote from Berivan, where she claims her innocence, stating:

I am 15 years old and I have entered prison for the first time. I constantly cry here, and I am unable to get use to it. I want to be together with my family. It is so painful. I want to get out of here and go to school. I have nothing to do with politics. I am waiting for you (someone) to do something about this.”

Following this, Berivan’s mother addresses an important point asking “was she charged with murder? Even people charged with murder do not receive such sentences…,” and adds that “I have not been able to see my daughter’s face for three months and I pleading for them just to leave my daughter alone..”

In addition to Taraf and Sabah, I also came across articles on the topic in the alternative news site, Bianet. Stating different statistics, it appears that in the last three years almost 3000 minors have been tried under the anti-Terrorist act; with most of the sentences ranging from 6-24 years.* In 2009, almost 1300 children were detained or sentenced in the South-Eastern part of the Turkey. However, due to the mass-migration of Kurds to the western part of Turkey in the 1990’s, similar problems have been imported to Istanbul, Mersin, and Adana. While I have not found statistics relating to Istanbul, Adana’s record of child imprisonment seems particularly alarming according to another article in Bianet, which expands also on the troubling conditions they face once in prison.**

For the time being, changes to the anti-Terrorist orders concerning children are held up in the Turkish parliament, and once –or if- passed, such children will be tried in special courts for minors. However, it is important to remember that it was the AKP that originally made these matters worse when in 2006 the Law on Terrorism was amended allowing minors 15-18 to be tried as adults. Lastly, it has been made clear that the amendments in the parliament will not serve as a solution to all the cases; especially for the children sentenced to 90 months or more. Importantly, last year Turkey was penalized by the European Human Rights Court for sentencing a 14-year old for belonging to an illegal organization.

The children being held simply have fallen victim to the decades old struggle between the Kurdish Southeast and the Turkish state/authorities. To claim rock throwing is equal to terrorism is absurd, and to sentence children, who are clearly living a civilian life, for belonging to a “terrorist organization,” is even more so; not to mention the inflated sentences. And, what does the future hold for all of these children who will spend years behind bars. Does anyone believe that this will serve as a reconciling point and that upon their release they will become better Turkish citizens. Not many words need to be added. The tragedy of the story stands on its own.

*This is a correction from the original blog posted. **Once I receive exact statistics of the exact number being serving time, I will publish them.

Taraf’s Ahmet Altan’s article:

Taraf’s article about Berivan

The other link entitled “Üç bin çoçuk TMK mağduru (28-01-10), I was not able to locate online.
Below are three articles for Bianet (in English), which I also consulted:


  1. Mary Hares FranklinFebruary 10, 2010 at 1:34 PM

    This ghastly story leaves me in tears. These are CHILDREN, for God's sake! I admit that when I read of such atrocities, I feel anger and enmity toward the perpetrator, even though my true values urge self-restraint. As these stories are publicized throughout the world, the nation of Turkey is shown in a disgraceful and despicable light. Surely they realize that? (Perhaps they don't care, or are counting on the language barrier to keep this info from the rest of the world.)
    Thanks, Louis.

  2. Dear Mary,

    Hope you receive this. I understand your reaction and believe you are right. In this case, yes, restraint is good; only due to the fact that they are trying to move this forward in the parliament to end this. I will follow this an update the blog of any changes.

    stay well-


  3. i wish that is only have been. not only berivan but every child of kurdısh under press and persecute. and we only want, world hears us noice, dont believe turkısh government. they, turkısh government, say we going to democratict. big lie, they killed,they do racism, they punished with prison.....

  4. what an insightful post! Getting these stories into global consciousness is half the battle.
    As a mother reading, about the arrest of children is heart wrenching.
    These "arrests" and "convictions" are a clear statement of what occurs when we allow fear and paranoia to prevail.

  5. We offer escorted group tours of Western and Eastern turkey and private tours to suit all budgets.Or perhaps you already have most of your travel booked and would like us to help with booking some extras such as blue cruises or Balloon Flights - Turkey is a magical and diverse country - whether you want to get into the nightlife of Istanbul, sit around drinking tea with the locals, camp under the stars, go trekking, learn about the culture or dive into the pristine waters of the Meditteranean, there is an experience to suit you. Whatever your needs, our aim is to make sure you have a memorable experience in Turkey.We aim to provide our clients with something different when they travel with us. As our client you won't miss all of the main tourist sites, but we aim to give you something more than just the basics - for example, the opportunity to visit a small Turkish village, or the chance to learn how to cook a delicious Turkish meal.
    We have many years experience in the Turkish travel and tourism industry and would like to share our experience and passion for Turkey with you.